There’s an old puzzle about a donkey.
It’s hungry, and it stands exactly halfway between two identical bales of hay. Same size, same smell, same distance. Since there’s no reason to prefer one over the other, the donkey can’t choose. So it stands there, perfectly rational, perfectly undecided, until it starves to death.
The puzzle is named after Jean Buridan, a fourteenth-century French philosopher, which is a little unfair, because it doesn’t appear anywhere in his surviving writings. Philosophers have argued about it for six hundred years. Farmers, presumably, have not, having noticed that real donkeys simply walk over and eat one.
But the donkey has a point worth taking seriously. When two options look equally good, more thinking doesn’t help. It just takes longer. And all the while, the hay you’re not eating is the cost.
We see a version of this more often than you might expect.
A client comes to us with a decision to make. Usually a big one: what to do with the proceeds of a sale, how to restructure a pension, whether and how to start passing wealth to the next generation. We do the work, and we come back with a recommendation. Not a perfect one, because perfect isn’t available, but a good one that fits.
And sometimes the response is: let’s look at everything. Every alternative, in full detail, before we commit to anything.
That instinct is completely understandable. These are large sums and serious decisions, and due diligence is a virtue. Some decisions genuinely do deserve more time. But there’s a point at which examining the options stops protecting you and starts costing you, and it’s surprisingly easy to sail past it without noticing.
Carl Richards, the planner and writer behind The Behavior Gap, discussed this recently on the Kitces & Carl podcast, in an episode about why keeping your options open can be riskier than committing. He describes it with an imaginary battery. Say you have ten units of energy for any big decision. Many of us spend eight of them deciding, agonising over every alternative, and leave just two for making the decision work once we’ve made it. Carl’s suggestion is to flip that: spend two units deciding, and eight making it work.
There’s good evidence behind the instinct.
In a study published in 2002, the psychologists Daniel Gilbert and Jane Ebert recruited Harvard students for a black-and-white photography course. Each student printed their two favourite photographs, then had to keep one and hand the other over. Half were told the decision was final. The other half were told they could swap within a few days if they changed their minds.
You’d expect the second group to be happier. They had an escape hatch.
They weren’t. The students whose choice was final grew fonder of the photo they’d kept. The students who could still swap liked theirs less. Keeping the option open didn’t make them more satisfied; it kept them comparing. And here’s the twist: when Gilbert and Ebert asked people in advance, they predicted the option to change would make no difference, and in a follow-up study about two-thirds chose the changeable option anyway.
We systematically overvalue having options and undervalue commitment. Once a decision is made, we stop relitigating it and start making it work, and the making-it-work is often where most of the value lies.
In financial planning, that matters in two ways.
The first is emotional, and it’s the Gilbert and Ebert point: a decision you keep reopening is a decision you never feel good about.
The second is financial. Indefinite deferral is itself a decision, and rarely a neutral one. Cash sits uninvested. Allowances that reset each April are lost. Gifts that start a seven-year clock don’t start it. Planning that needs to be in place before April 2027, when pensions enter the estate for inheritance tax, edges closer to the deadline. We wrote last month about Tim Harford’s point that every yes is also a no. Every “not yet” is a choice too, with costs that simply don’t show up on the page.
None of this means accepting the first idea anyone puts in front of you. A good adviser should welcome questions and be able to explain why one route was chosen over another. The point is narrower than that. After the Budget, plenty of people are tempted to wait until things settle. They rarely do. At some stage, more analysis stops making the decision better and only makes it later. Good enough, chosen and committed to, very often beats perfect and pending.
Buridan’s donkey had two perfectly good bales of hay. Either one would have done.
We help people in Hook and across Hampshire, Surrey, Berkshire, Sussex and Kent make the big decisions well, and then put the energy where it counts: into making them work.
Altor Wealth Management LLP is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA number 769033). Registered office: Landmark House, Station Road, Hook, Hampshire RG27 9HA. This article is general information, not personal advice. The value of investments can fall as well as rise. Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances and is based on current legislation, which can change. Client situations described are composites, not individual cases. Research referenced: Gilbert & Ebert (2002), Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
