Who Owns the Abundance?

In 1930, John Maynard Keynes sat down to imagine the world of his grandchildren. Technology and compound growth, he reasoned, would make us so productive that within a hundred years the problem of earning a living would be largely solved. We’d work perhaps fifteen hours a week, “three-hour shifts”, and the great challenge of the age would be working out what to do with all that leisure.

He gave it until 2030. We have a little over three years left.

How’s your week looking?

The promise has never quite gone away; it just changes its clothes. For decades it was automation, then computers, that would hand us the three-day week. Today it’s artificial intelligence, and the pitch comes from the people building it. In November 2023, after the AI Safety Summit at Bletchley Park, Elon Musk sat on a stage in London with the Prime Minister and told him: “There will come a point where no job is needed.” And not to worry, he added. “We won’t have universal basic income, we’ll have universal high income.”

Let’s leave aside, for now, whether that abundance arrives, and whether it’ll be shared any more evenly than the last few rounds of technological progress were. There’s a narrower question that matters a great deal to anyone living, working or investing in Britain.

If the abundance does arrive, who will own it?

The companies building the leading AI models are, overwhelmingly, American, with China the only serious rival. Europe has one notable contender in France’s Mistral. Britain had one of the finest AI laboratories in the world, DeepMind, founded in London in 2010. Google bought it in 2014.

Interestingly, the Americans have started asking the ownership question out loud, from both ends of their politics. Sam Altman’s OpenAI has offered to put around 5% of its equity into a public wealth fund whose returns would flow to American citizens; the terms are undefined and nothing is binding yet. Senator Bernie Sanders has gone much further, with a bill that would place half of the largest AI companies into a fund he values at $7 trillion, paying every American more than $1,000 a year. Neither is law, and plenty think neither should be. But notice what’s being discussed: AI as a national asset, with the public as shareholders.

Now look at our side of the Atlantic. British businesses and households are paying subscriptions to American AI firms. Those revenues become American profits, which become American share prices, which, if any of these schemes come to pass, become American dividends. If AI really does replace large amounts of British work, the wages and the income tax that went with them shrink here, while the profits accrue there. Nobody is proposing to hand Britons shares in anything.

We’ve been here before.

In the 1970s, Britain and Norway found themselves sharing one of the great windfalls of the century: North Sea oil. Britain spent its revenues as they came in. Norway put its surplus into a fund, established in 1990. That fund is now worth more than $2.2 trillion, something over $390,000 for every Norwegian. The oil belonged to both countries. The abundance ended up belonging to one.

This time, Britain doesn’t even own the oil.

Could that be the biggest economic problem facing the UK, and Europe, over the next decade? It’s a genuine question rather than a prediction. The technology may disappoint, or the gains may spread in ways nobody expects. But a country that consumes a transformative technology without owning any of it is at least taking a risk it should be talking about, and we hear surprisingly little of that conversation in Westminster.

There is a more personal point here, and a more encouraging one.

You don’t have to wait for the government to give you shares. Anyone holding a globally diversified portfolio already owns a slice of the world’s largest companies, AI firms included, in proportion to their size. A portfolio that leans heavily on the UK, as many British investors’ portfolios historically have, owns much less of them. It’s one reason we tend to think about investing globally rather than from home.

That comes with a caution of its own. A handful of very large American technology companies now make up an unusually big share of global stock markets, and their prices already assume a great deal of future success. Owning a share of the abundance is not the same as being guaranteed one. Diversification is about not betting everything on any single story, including this one.

Keynes, for what it’s worth, worried most about what we’d do with all that spare time. If he were writing now, he might be more worried about who owned it.

We help people in Hook and across Hampshire, Surrey, Berkshire, Sussex and Kent build portfolios that are wide enough to share in the world’s growth, wherever it turns up, without staking the future on any one part of it.


Altor Wealth Management LLP is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA number 769033). Registered office: Landmark House, Station Road, Hook, Hampshire RG27 9HA. This article is general information and commentary, not personal advice or a recommendation to buy any investment. The value of investments can fall as well as rise and you may get back less than you invest. Concentration in a small number of companies or sectors increases risk.

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top

Discover more from Altor Wealth

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading